309: Action and Reflection
Dear friends,
/strategy
“[Complex] problems are best tackled, not by moral algebra, but obliquely: they involve high-level objectives achieved through adaptation and iteration, with constant rebalancing of incompatible and incommensurable components that are imperfectly known but acquired as the process goes on.”
So writes John Kay in Obliquity: Why Our Goals Are Best Achieved Indirectly. It is a book which advises, “… rely(ing) on carrots and sticks alone is effective only when we employ donkeys, and we are sure exactly what we want the donkeys to do. Directness is appropriate when the environment is stable, and objectives are one-dimensional and transparent… And only then.”
I was reminded of Kay when I encountered this fable in Helen Nde’s Book of African Folklore.
“Long ago, when everything in the world – even animals – could talk, there lived a hedgehog. One day, the other animals said to him:
‘We have to decide who will command us all. How are we going to do this?’
Hedgehog said to them: ‘Let us get up well before dawn. Whoever sees the Sun first, that one will command us all!’
They all came together at dawn – everything that God counts as living creatures. The animals looked toward the east, but Hedgehog looked toward a nearby plain.
‘Turn around!’ some animals said to him. ‘Don’t you know the Sun comes from the east? Over there where the mountains are?’
‘You can look over there if you want,’ Hedgehog said. ‘Even if it makes no sense, I will look at the plain.’
The animals returned to looking at the east. The Sun finally came, its rays lightly caressing the hills hidden by the mountain. But the plains, away from the mountain’s shadow, glowed in the dawn rays. When Hedgehog saw that the plain was lit up, he shouted to the other animals:
‘Here he is, my children, that’s it, he’s here!’
To which the animals replied: ‘You are our leader!’”
In the introduction to A New Way to Think: Your Guide to Superior Management Effectiveness, master strategist Roger Martin describes when he was hired by a firm to figure out why their R&D department was producing smaller and smaller wins.
They were confused. They had implemented a rigorous screening model that eliminated unlikely prospects, but their success rate kept falling.
Martin reflects: “the screening methodology the client used involved projecting future sales based on currently existing data. This meant that for innovations that were minor variations on the status quo, relatively compelling data tended to be available, and these projects consistently made it through the various gates. For more breakthrough innovations, however, there just wasn’t good data available (because the ideas were new), and hence, projections of huge future sales tended to be dismissed as speculative. In other words, the seemingly sensible model was logically flawed: it was predicated on the availability of good market data, but existing market data is not likely to be relevant for genuinely breakthrough innovations”.
Drawing on philosopher Charles Sanders Peirce’s insight that no new idea has been proven analytically in advance, Martin advised them to first screen the ideas on the strength of their internal logic and then to systematically look for ways to gather data as the project unfolded.
Our thinking must match the world’s complexity. Sometimes we must look away from the crowd. Sometimes we must eradicate the obvious. But we must always act. Ultimately, it is the only way to know.
//self
London Business School professor Herminia Ibarra based Working Identity: Unconventional Strategies for Reinventing Your Career on “two disarmingly simple ideas. First, our working identity is not a hidden treasure waiting to be discovered at the very core of our inner being. Rather, it is made up of many possibilities: some tangible and concrete, defined by the things we do, the company we keep, and the stories we tell about our work and lives; others existing only in the realm of future potential and private dreams. Second, changing careers means changing ourselves, reworking our identities. Since we are many selves, changing is not about swapping one identity for another but rather a transition process in which we reconfigure the full set of possibilities. These simple ideas alter everything we take for granted about finding a new career. They ask us to devote the greater part of our time and energy to action rather than reflection, to doing instead of planning. Hence, the unconventional strategies.”
This is true not only for changing careers, but also for new roles, especially when they come with new levels of authority and new stakeholders.
Our previous successes got us the job. However, those same patterns, behaviours, and habits are probably not all the new situation needs.
Success requires knowing what has changed, what this new context requires, and acting accordingly.
This is also true when recruiting people into new roles. Be aware: what does this job require that they’ve not done before? Remember: you can’t instruct change. It must be mentored, coached and demonstrated. Identify the gap. Co-create the plan. If they tell you they don’t need help, ignore them; they will.
Ibarra advises, “Act your way into a new way of thinking and being. You cannot discover yourself by introspection. Start by changing what you do. Try different paths. Take action and then use the feedback from your actions to figure out what you want. Don’t try to analyze or plan your way into a new career. Conventional strategies advocated by self-assessment manuals and traditional career counselors would have you start by looking inside. Start instead by stepping out. Be attentive to what each step teaches you and make sure that each step helps you take the next.”
Like Martin’s breakthrough innovations, the best data comes through intentional, considered action and reflection.
///soul
I’ve been chewing on two quotations. One from psychiatrist Mark Epstein, the other from psychologist Tara Brach.
“When we refuse to acknowledge the presence of unwanted feelings, we are as bound to them as when we give ourselves over to them indignantly and self-righteously.”
“’I’m just speaking my truth’ can sound honest while still leaving something important unexplored. Sometimes anger is true. And underneath it, hurt is also true. Blame may be present. And underneath it, fear.
Before speaking, we might ask: What’s underneath this? Truth often has layers.”
Best wishes,
Karl
PS: You can learn more about my coaching practice here and subscribe to this letter here.
