310: Learning from… Robin Wall Kimmerer, Krista Tippett, Maggie O’Farrell & moss
Dear Friends
It’s been a while since we spoke about wine. Last week, at chef Arno Janse van Rensburg’s recently opened Fieldblend Wine Bar – tucked into the back of a Simonstown Victorian, next to old stables that are transmogrifying into a potter’s studio – I discovered Sam Lambson’s Blue Canary, a very drinkable carbonic Syrah, perfect for a warmish afternoon in early summer and very happy alongside my smoked yellowtail pâté.
As the wind picked up and the chill crept off the ocean and into the courtyard, I swopped to a big blend, La Vierge’s The Upside Down Tree of Life. It joined a delicious, kind-of-steak-tartare remix, served with seepampoentjie leaves that worked as taco shells (for those not from South Africa, seepampoentjie is a dune succulent – the kind that makes tortoises smile).
Neither wine is a bank-busting award-winner. They are yummy. Very.
/strategy
It’s the time of year when our attention turns to planning and maybe, hopefully, also dreaming, for ourselves and our organisations.
In that context, I thought this anecdote from botanist and scientist Robin Wall Kimmerer was a useful provocation.
“You know, moss in our language. We call them Asakmek. They are the blanket of Mother Earth. They’re that comforting beginning place for so much of life. They’re the oldest beings, the oldest plants on the planet… mosses who are practitioners of the small, practitioners of taking very little and giving a lot back… in the evolutionary history of the world, 99.9% of all the beings who have ever lived are extinct. The mosses, the most ancient, are almost unchanged from their origins.
And so, what are they teaching us? … first of all, they must have got something right, and I think it’s in that smallness… I think they’re asking us to redefine what does it mean to be successful. They’re not the biggest. They’re not the showiest… But their metric of success is that they’ve lasted, and they have created beauty and diversity. And when I am with them, they help me remember that, that there are lots of ways to be successful, and they show us one that lasts, that has lasted through every climate change the Earth has ever experienced. Mosses came out on the other side. Shouldn’t we be paying attention to that?”
(This anecdote is an extract from an OnBeing Podcast conversation: To Bring Life into a Trembling World).
//self
Kimmerer reflects that at university, “I was told that we were there to learn about plants. And from the Anishinaabe perspective, they go, ‘Oh, no, we’re here to learn from plants’… learning from plants means that we are understanding them as beings with agency, right? With their own stories, their own creation stories, their own intelligences. And so, it’s a very different kind of listening. It’s using those intuitive tools as well as empirical tools to be able to listen to the natural world.”
We can apply this model in all contexts.
I see it most often with founders; in their businesses’ early days, they’re eager, curious, sometimes quite desperate, to learn from their customers; they understand them as people with aspirations and hopes just like theirs. As the businesses scale, that gets lost: customers become spreadsheet items with projections attached; they get put in pipelines; curiosity and care get replaced by categorisation. The best ones weave them together, keeping connection at the core.
Kimmerer and podcast host, Krista Tippett, riff on ‘remember’, a reminder that we are members.
Tippett observes, “we don’t have to invent or create our kinship with all of life. It is our natural state, right? It’s there for us to reorient towards, to re-member”.
This is true in all contexts. We are social and communal beings. Yes, the world is filled with terrible divisions that cause horrific violence. Underneath is a fundamental truth: we are all connected.
That may feel too large for the 15th of November at the end of a long year, in what feels like the longest decade that I’ve been alive (having been born in 1973).
Think of it in this simple way – the labels we use in business-life: marketing-says, finance-wants, sales-has-run-ahead-and-done, tech-is-delayed-again… what might we enable if we remember that we’re all kin, in community, living lives, and trying to make sense of it all?
Kimmerer reflects that in her nation’s language, Potawatomi, they never speak of plants as ‘its’.
She says, “I would never say, ‘It is asking really good questions,’ right? That would be so disrespectful. But in English, that’s how we speak of the living world”.
Powerful.
How often do we create ‘its’ of others? Experiment: instead of saying ‘customer ’, speak about the person who works for that business; instead of ‘head office’, use the person’s name.
///soul
Maggie O’ Farrell’s Land is many things.
Tomás is an Irish cartographer. He works for English invaders. He takes pride in his work. The soldiers sign and submit his maps with their names. In their reports he is ‘the labourer’.
Tomás’ life reminds us that it was Ireland where England first practised imperialism.
He, like so many, like his wife, Phina, whom he met in and rescued from a workhouse, was orphaned by the Irish famine. He’s not sure he remembers home – memory feels like mist. Her father returns from America to fetch his family. He is told his family has died.
Tomás loves the land on which they live – “…its rituals and routines are inscribed in their bodies and minds… it is in their original map… ”.
O’ Farrell describes a land that is as alive as the beings that live on it. The old place names recognise this. They describe in intimate detail the fish that spawn there, the type of wind that blows. Empire eradicates the life-reflecting-giving names.
The names we use. Matter. For People. For Places. Words create the reality we live.
When his son Liam declares he wants to be a priest, he responds, “I have no argument with the idea of faith, you know that. But can you not put your faith in what is beneath your feet? The rocks under the earth, the inexorable shift of soil down a mountainside, the pull of the moon… and when we die, we surrender our bodies to the earth and we become earth. It is the end of one story but the beginning of another”.
If we pay attention, heaven can be here.
When Liam leaves for the novitiate, he calls out, to ask Tomás to say goodbye, but stops mid-sentence. Tomás does not look up – continues working – he too, can’t find the words. In this land, there is just too much pain to be expressed; the only way to survive was to lock the pain away. But with it goes life.
Sometimes, it is too painful to put into words. Sometimes, we don’t know the words. Literally. Sometimes, listening must include the silence.
Years later, Liam receives news of his father’s death. The next morning, a fellow priest ends the morning prayer: Tomás is now in heaven. Liam is struck by its absurdity. Tomás loved the land and the spirits that moved in it; his heaven was the earth on which he stood. If he was anywhere, he was there, walking in the forest, staring into deep pools shaded by ancient trees. Liam’s faith evaporates. In the following weeks, the elders of his order try to persuade him that he is mistaken. They fail. He is no longer who he was.
Life is like that. It looks the same. We look the same. It is not. We are not. Change has come and, so, change must come.
Wishing you love and luck as you observe the change that has come; wishing you the silence you need to see.
Karl
PS: You can learn more about my coaching practice here and subscribe to this letter here.
