311: Leadership Lessons from Zakes Mda’s Chris Hani: A Life of Courage and Compassion
Good morning friends
Next week’s letter will be this year’s last. I am using December to turn my attention back to long-form writing. We’ll return on 9 or 16 January; I’m still deciding which.
This year, I’ve been relatively quiet about restaurants and the like, but if you are coming to Cape Town over summer, John Joseph’s recently opened Briquette is worth visiting. Get there in time for sundowners. Joseph says the restaurant is a homage to his ouma’s cooking. It definitely has strong echoes of rural South African Sunday braais, but his granny must’ve been a fancy cook. Yummy food, great views and Cape Town buzzy. If you’re looking for something low-key and informal, perhaps after a day’s surfing, then Carla’s Mozambique Restaurant in Muizenberg is hard to beat. It’s BYOB. Eat the prawns. You’ll be happy.
I’ll squeeze in one or two more suggestions next week. Let’s get to it.
/strategy
For this week’s strategy, I am going to lean entirely on Justice Albie Sachs’ introduction to Zakes Mda’s Chris Hani: A Life of Courage and Compassion. Sachs is a former Constitutional Court judge, survivor of a 1988 car bomb planted by apartheid agents, and he helped Hani escape South Africa.
I love poet John O’Donohue’s For a Leader. Sachs’ description of Hani gives us what it means to live and lead like the poem; it is one of the best descriptions of leadership I have read. I see no reason to add to it.
“Chris Hani was openly beloved and admired for his bravery and personal charisma. But there is a deeper ‘why’ for his popularity, one that continues to this day. A major element was that his main focus was always on the working people of town and countryside, and that he always strongly affirmed the rights of women. But more than that, he hated abuses of power and detested corruption and use of the struggle for personal advancement. In addition, he was a rounded person of deep intellectual substance, who confronted real hard issues in a direct, wholehearted and coherent manner. He lived not by slogans alone. His fame emerged not from the incantation of popular chants or the raucous denigration of easy targets. His challenges were not aimed at individuals but rather at maintaining principled political and moral integrity. He believed strongly in the collective, the importance of teamwork, and of open, inclusive and honest discussion before decisions were taken.
At the same time, Chris never became one of those apparatchiks who lost their spirit and soul to the apparatus of struggle and simply mouthed the party line. He kept his body fit and his mind ever active. He got a kick out of being a robust individual personality in a disciplined collective movement. He delighted in seizing whatever opportunities he could to convey freely and directly exactly how he believed matters should be taken forward. As far as his own personal choices were concerned, he was always ready to take the difficult road; it was not about him; it was about liberation. He became famous because he did not seek to become famous.
I can’t say what it was about him that I loved the most. Was it his deep sense of honour? Was it his unrestrained eagerness to learn everything possible about the world and human history? Was it his openness of mind to all ideas, and warm engagement with the greatest range of people? Was it his intuitive adherence to principle? Was it his spontaneous anger at oppression and his intuitive empathy with people who were being subjected to unfairness? Was it his bravery? Was it his sense of fun? Was it his joy?
Was it his natural solidarity with people throughout South Africa and the world struggling for their dignity and rights? Perhaps it was all of these, and more, together.”
//self
If you’re not South African, you might not know Chris Hani. He was the chief of staff of uMkhonto we Sizwe, the former armed wing of the African National Congress. He was loved for his heroism and his integrity. Amongst innumerable achievements, he notably drafted a stinging memorandum in 1969 criticising the ANC’s exile leadership of nepotism and other sins. The leadership reacted with fury. He was expelled (and later reinstated) from the ANC, but ultimately his critique led to reform. He was murdered by right-wing assassins on 10 April 1993.
Mda’s recently published Chris Hani: A Life of Courage and Compassion tells Hani’s story.
When someone is as significant as Hani, it is easy to lose sight of their humanity. They become more myth than human.
Mda gives us the Hani whose first marital home with his wife Limpho was a one-roomed concrete-block house with an outdoor toilet; whose wedding reception was burgers for two at a fast-food restaurant; the Hani who was a trained guerrilla determined to infiltrate and overthrow apartheid South Africa but couldn’t ride a bicycle; and the Hani who, in the aftermath of the Hwange campaign in which he had killed, imprisonment in Botswana and then the wrath that followed his 1969 memo, broke down and retreated to northern Zambia to heal.
In this telling, Mda reflects the humanity that was the core of Hani’s leadership.
Hani remembered names and families. He valued the people around him; a former bodyguard reflected, “He treated us like his comrades, not like his servants. He followed up on every nitty-gritty. When a comrade had run out of underwear or socks, Comrade Chris would follow the matter up… he followed up no matter how small the matter was.”
As the ANC grew and recruited many from different political traditions, Hani told them, “You are new as you’ve just arrived to join the ANC. Some of you arrived as former members of the PAC and some as members of other organisations. You must never make the mistake of thinking you are better than other people, those of a different ideological world view. Don’t focus on the differences between yourselves and them, but on what unites you. What unites us all is the common enemy – the apartheid government”.
Mda tells us that this was one of Hani’s superpowers: to articulate the vision, to remind people that whatever their differences, they had a larger purpose and so they should not spend energy on the differences but accept (or solve if essential) them so that the ambition of freedom could be pursued.
On any given day, Hani met with diverse groups: white students from the Wits University SRC, a Women’s League delegation from Western Province – seasoned ANC activists mostly from Coloured communities, trade unionists from the Transvaal, a group of intellectual peers who debated among themselves issues in Marxism-Leninism. Mda comments, “His flexibility was astounding. He effortlessly adapted to the register of the group he was speaking with at any one time.”
Hani was committed to learning. He took every opportunity for intellectual debate, sometimes to the annoyance of his comrades. One reflects, “What I hated with Chris and Skweyiya was that even when we were in the middle of marching in the bush, they would be talking big English, and I would say to the other comrades, ‘Oh God, we are going to die from dialectical materialism’”.
Mda says that, whilst imprisoned in Botswana, Hani and comrades devoured books – “They turned the prison into an institution of higher learning”.
///soul
Mandla Langa in The Lost Language of the Soul called Oliver Tambo ‘the best president South Africa never had’.
Mda’s history adds weight to that declaration. When the Luthuli Detachment, of which Hani was a member, prepared to deploy into then-Rhodesia, Tambo was with them, sleeping out in the bush, in the open alongside the soldiers.
One of the combatants, Alfred Willie, reflects, “I respect Tambo for one thing, he participated in everything we did. He was not a bystander. He did everything no matter how difficult or dangerous it might seem to be. If he saw you do something, he did it too. I remember him getting down to the crossing point to see it himself”. In this instance, it included abseiling down steep cliffs to the bank of the Zambezi. It was an involved, side-by-side, hands-on leadership that Hani emulated.
I’ll leave you with this remembrance from one of Hani’s comrades, Khotso Matli, who said, “Comrade Chris told us we had lived with the Boers for centuries now, and we could not just say that because they abused us, they didn’t qualify to be citizens of this country. It’s one reason I always say Chris made us humans. Chris raised us not only politically but as wholesome people”.
Yours in reflection
Karl
PS: You may also appreciate these letters:
- Leading in Crises (Mandela’s leadership after Hani’s assassination) — https://karlgostner.com/157-leading-in-crises/
- David Sengeh’s Radical Inclusion — https://karlgostner.com/179-david-sengeh-radical-inclusion/
- Leadership Lessons from Caster Semenya — https://karlgostner.com/207-leadership-lessons-from-caster-semenya/
- Some Leadership Lessons (Wangari Maathai) — https://karlgostner.com/some-leadership-lessons/
- The Man Who Planted Trees and Zohran Mamdani — https://karlgostner.com/254-the-man-who-planted-trees-and-zohran-mamdani/
- Better Humans Make Better Leaders — https://karlgostner.com/better-humans-make-better-leaders/
- The Inner Work of Leadership: Caring for Yourself and Others — https://karlgostner.com/210-self-care-for-leaders/
- You can’t fake leadership (Hitendra Wadhwa) — https://karlgostner.com/199-you-cant-fake-leadership-lessons-from-hitendra-wadhwas-small-actions-make-great-leaders/
