307: The Life Cycle of a CEO
Good morning friends
One of this letter’s joys is that frequently books are delivered with notes that read, “Love your newsletter; think you might enjoy this”.
Claudius Hildebrand and Robert Stark’s The Life Cycle of a CEO was one such delivery.
Thank you, Guy Lundy, for your generosity. It is the core of this week’s letter.
/strategy
It’s a mistake we all make. The situation changes. We don’t adapt. We continue as we always have.
Often, we identify the change – a new competitor, our customers are grumbling, staff turnover has nudged up – but still fail to act, as if the diagnosis itself was sufficient, which, of course, it never is.
We miss it in business life in more subtle ways: new people join our team; we welcome them and carry on.
Yet, think about your favourite sport. The Springboks play differently depending on whether Handré Pollard, Manie Libbok or Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu are at flyhalf. You’d be appalled if the game plan didn’t change. Or imagine you get to play in the Wimbledon doubles final. For the first set, your partner is Serena Williams, for the second set, Roger Federer.
Do you keep working in the same old way when your Exco changes? Quite probably. Do you have the conversation, “Things have changed, how should we adjust our action?” Probably not.
The Life Cycle of a CEO’s utility rests in this oft-ignored fact: change will happen and as change happens, change must happen.
Hildebrand and Stark wrote it for CEOs, based on the research about CEOs. Its insights apply to all of us.
All jobs, and relationships, have life cycles. Each new cycle must be identified, and action must be adjusted to meet its unique needs. We call it strategy.
Hildebrand and Stark identify seven phases in the CEO’s Life Cycle – ascent; launch; calibration; reinvention; the complacency trap; building legacy and succeeding with succession.
For each phase they tell anecdotes of success and failure and suggest responses to take and pitfalls to avoid; gifting us mental models which strengthen our pattern recognising capabilities, enabling us to select context-appropriate responses.
Here are two examples.
The ascent phase: if you want to be a CEO contender, be deliberate in your career construction: bank experience across diverse parts of the business. Include some aspect of growth – sales, business development, or new product launch. CEOs with broad experience do better than specialists. CEOs that understand customers and growth also do better.
The launch phase: a third of CEOs don’t last more than three years in the role.
Why?
Well, in part, because when they start everyone is enthused – employees give support, the stock price lifts, the board thinks they’re geniuses for finding this person – then after a year, we realise that we’ve appointed a human not a superhero and the enthusiasm dips. If we are not conscious that the dip is a human process, we start to think and then act as if we’ve made a mistake – micro-managing the executive, having sidebar meetings about them etcetera – setting up a destructive and self-fulfilling cycle.
The reverse is also true. We join a company. This one, we are sure, will be heaven. A year later the choirs of angels are a little discordant. We start thinking we’ve made a terrible mistake.
We may well have made a mistake. However, it is useful to slow down, know that some of the discord is simply the part of the cycle we’re in and calibrate accordingly.
Similarly, they tell us complacency sets in around year five – not just the CEO, but typically the broader executive team and the Board. It is a useful exercise to treat it as absolute fact: It is Year Five, let us assume that we have become complacent – because the research suggests it is highly probable that we have – what must we change?
This will sting: “When CEOs depart during the Complacency Trap stage of the life cycle, generally from years six to ten, inefficiencies that have crept into the organization and problems that have been festering— such as an underperforming unit or product line— constitute much of the low-hanging fruit their successors immediately go after. This invites the question: If those problems are so apparent to new leaders and boards that appoint them, why haven’t they been more effectively addressed?”
Identifying the phases and knowing their patterns helps us be better.
Here are two more of my favourite insights:
“High performers invest in growth vigorously. First, they fund growth by investing more in acquiring, upgrading, and maintaining their physical assets, such as property, plants, buildings, and technology. Their capital expenditure (CapEx) relative to sales rises considerably higher, from 12 percent in year one to 17 percent in year five. The low performers, but contrast, cut their CapEx spend from 9 percent to 6 percent in the corresponding period, attempting to save their way to prosperity. The high performers also invest more in innovation by driving up their R&D spend by 40 percent, from 10 percent to 14 percent by year five; the low performers’ R&D spend remains flat. Finally, after doing fewer M&A activities in their first three years, the high performers do more in year four, averaging roughly one acquisition annually from then on. The low performers engage in more M&A in the first three years, but it tails off, and the high performers overtake them in activity in year four”.
AND
“… research finds that when done effectively, culture change produces impressive results. Key is that specific desired changes in behaviour are articulated in clear alignment with the company’s strategy, not treated as separate from the core drivers of the company’s success. A recent survey of five hundred CEOs of global companies found that ‘most [of them] aren’t particularly intentional in their pursuit of culture as a core driver of financial performance.’ Those who said they did see culture as a core driver of financial results, however, led companies that saw significantly greater revenue growth over a three-year period, a compounded annual growth rate (CAGR) of 9.1 percent versus 4.4 percent for the firms led by respondents who indicated they didn’t see culture as key to improving results”.
Simply, successful leaders care about growth and care about culture; true for leadership, true for life.
//self
Chief Executive Officer. It is a title. It is also, always, a person. Companies are also, always, composed of people. Self-evident. Easy to forget.
The most effective CEOs invest in being better people and making people better:
“Analysis of how different leadership styles matched with performance showed that the highest performers were the most accomplished in influencing through empowerment. This is not to say that the directive style of leadership is never appropriate. Some situations call for it, for example, crisis management. But generally, the best results come from leading through empowering others” and “Most successful leaders not only are receptive to critiques of their abilities and management style but also proactively seek feedback”.
///soul
Mark Epstein’s The Zen of Therapy recounts this koan: A monk asked, “What is the substance of the true person?” The Master said, “Spring, summer, autumn, winter.” The monk said, “In that case, it is hard for me to understand.” The Master said, “You asked about the substance of the true person, didn’t you?”
Whether company, country or person we all have seasons. Each requires its own approach. It has always been so.
All the best
Karl
PS: If you’re a CEO or senior exec and want to work with someone who will challenge you, who will help you strengthen your pattern recognition capabilities and your capacity for strategic action, you might want to work with me. You can find out more here.
